“But you are not to be called ‘Rabbi’, for you have only one teacher, and all of you are brothers. And don’t call anyone on earth ‘Father,’ for you have only one Father, the one in heaven. Nor are you to be called ‘Teachers,’ for you have only one teacher, the Christ! (Matthew 23:8-10)
No one enjoys a good conspiracy theory more than me, and when I scroll social media sites, I’m still confronted with lots of conspiracy theories about the Bible:
- That Jesus really survived the crucifixion and went on to marry Mary Magdalent and have children.
- That it hadn’t occurred to anybody to think of Jesus as God until the Council of Nicea in the yeare 325
- That Jesus travelled to India during the so-called “lost years”, learned Buddhism in Tibet and was even initiated into the Egyptian mystery religions.
What all these theories have in common is the conviction that the Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church has been covering up the truth for centuries by removing certain books from the Bible and deleting verses that don’t fit the official narrative.
My issue with that is, if the church has been deleting verses that embarrass them, why the hell didn’t they delete this verse – “Call no man ‘Father’” (Matthew 23:9). The church has been calling its priests ‘Father’ for the last 2,000 years!
I used to hear this verse quoted a lot when I was at seminary in the 1980’s. I was at an Evangelical seminary where we were indeed training to be priests but none of my colleagues ever intended to be called ‘Father’. That was forbidden by Jesus! No! We considered ourselves ‘teachers’ – a title, ironically, also forbidden by Jesus!
“Don’t call anyone on earth ‘Father,’ says Jesus, “Nor are you to be called ‘Teachers” (Matthew 23:9-10)
Personally, I love being called ‘Father’, and I think I’m one of very few people who actually became a father twice in the same week. I was ordained in December 1989, only a few days after eldest daughter was born! I’ve been called ‘Father’ ever since, by my own children and by others, and I like it. Indeed, there was a period when my teenage son tried calling me by my first name and I did not appreciate that.
In truth, I’ve spent much of my life trying to function as a father figure to any number of young people who have fallen off the tracks, and I don’t think it inappropriate when they call me ‘Father’, and neither, I think, did Saint Paul:
“Never speak harshly to an older man, but appeal to him as if he were your father. Treat younger men like brothers, older women like mothers, and younger women like sisters.” (1Timothy 5:1-2)
The spiritual community is supposed to function like a family, and I don’t think it’s a problem to recognise those who play motherly and fatherly roles within our communities. Even so, Jesus was making a point, and it was about equality.
“For you have only one teacher, and all of you are brothers” (“and sisters” He would have added, had any of his female disciples been present). It’s about equality! We are ultimately all equals, and so nobody has the right to lord it over anybody else as if they were superior to them. It’s not really about words – Rabbi, Father, Mother or teacher – but about the way we relate to each other, and it’s about leadership!
There are two different forms of leadership on view here – one which is based on the wielding of power and one that is all about service:
“You know that the rulers of the gentiles lord it over them”, says Jesus, “and the leaders have complete authority. This, however, is not the way it shall be among you. If one of you wants to be great, you must be the servant of the rest; and if one of you wants to be first, you must be the slave of the others – like the Son of Man, who did not come to be served but to serve” (Matthew 20:25-28).
And here in chapter 23, “The greatest among you will be your servant. All who exalt themselves will be humbled, and all who humble themselves will be exalted.” (11-12)
Real leadership, Jesus says, is about humility and service, not about wielding power.
Some years ago I had the opportunity of speaking with Seyed Mohammad Khatami, former President of Iran, who was here promoting ‘dialogue between civilizations. I asked him then, “if we can get ordinary people to dialogue, can we get politicians to dialogue too?” to which he replied, “politicians never dialogue. They negotiate.”
I thought that brilliantly captured the way politicians work, where it’s all about maintaining control. The church isn’t supposed to function like that. Sadly though, ever since the Constantine won the battle of Milvian Bridge in the year 312, the church has held power, and history shows we’ve done everything we could to hang on to it. We exchanged the towel and basin for the throne and sceptre, and the results have been depressingly predictable: corruption, coercion, violence, scandal.
I don’t think Jesus or the Apostles ever intended the church to have institutional power. The great Dane, Soren Kierkegaard, spoke being in the Cathedral in Copenhagen, watching his grace the Archbishop of Copenhagen come forward in all his robes, with his miter and his attendants at the base of a great procession. And he read from Saint Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians – “God has chosen what is weak in the world to shame the strong” (1:27). And Kierkegaard said he looked around the Cathedral, and nobody else was laughing! How did they miss the joke?
It’s no joke really, is it – the sad history of the church? We’ve been plagued with corruption, sex scandals and violence, and the answer we’re given from Jesus here is not better management or tighter control. The answer is as it has always been:
“The greatest among you will be your servant. All who exalt themselves will be humbled, and all who humble themselves will be exalted.” (Matthew 23:11-12)
Perhaps the Church will recover its credibility at one day, but I suspect it won’t be when we learn how to wield power more effectively, but when we finally learn how to give it away.
First published in Father Dave’s weekly newsletter – October 31st, 2026